Dundee City Licensing Board - 05/02/2004

At the ADJOURNED MEETING of the DUNDEE CITY LICENSING BOARD held at Dundee on 5th February, 2004.

 

Present:-

 

Lord Provost John R LETFORD

 

Bailies

 

Helen WRIGHT

John CORRIGAN

Bruce D MACKIE

 

Neil I C POWRIE

 

 

Councillors

 

George REGAN

Fiona M GRANT

Andrew DAWSON

 

Nigel DON

 

 

Bailie POWRIE, Chairman, in the Chair.

 

The minute of meeting of the Board of 15th January, 2004 was held as read.

 

Unless marked thus * all items stand delegated.

 

Before considering the business on the agenda the Chairman informed the Board that a petition had been received from the Trades House Bar against the refusal of their Children's Certificate because of the Board's policy on smoking when their Children's Certificate was in operation and claiming they were being discriminated against.

 

The Chairman acknowledged receipt of the petition reiterating the Board's position that the condition relating to Children's Certificates and smoking would remain, that the Children's Certificate had not been refused but had been granted with the condition attached and that there was no discrimination by the Board towards the Trades House Bar.

 

The Chairman also acknowledged a letter from Deacon Brodie's which highlighted an exhibition of an air purification system to be held on 24th February 2004. The Board agreed that any interested member attend together with a representative from Environmental Health.

 

I LICENSING (SCOTLAND) ACT 1976

 

(a) APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL OF LICENCES

 

* Denotes Sunday Opening

$ Denotes Children's Certificates

 

 

Name

Address of Premises

Type of Licence

 

1

Ram Basra

95 Ancrum Road

Dundee

 

1/3 King Street

Dundee

(Town House)

Public House *$

 

The Board, having heard from an objector and an agent on behalf of the applicant agreed to refuse the above application.

 

 

2

Robert Bennett

28 Ashkirk Gardens

Dundee

 

22 St Andrew's Street

Dundee

DD1 2EX

(Jaffrey's Bar)

Public House

 

The Board, having heard from an objector and an agent on behalf of the applicant, the Chairman moved to grant the above application. As an amendment, the Lord Provost moved to refuse the application on the grounds that the applicant was not a fit and proper person.

 

On a division, there voted for the motion The Chairman, Bailie Mackie and Councillor Don (3); and for the amendment, the Lord Provost, Bailie Corrigan and Councillor Dawson (3); Bailie Wright and Councillors Grant and Regan being absent when the vote was taken.

 

There being a parity of votes the Chairman used his casting vote in favour of the motion granting the above application.

 

3

Cartplan Limited

Riverview Buildings

138 Nethergate

Dundee

DD1 4ED

and Tracy Ann Wares

61F Sandeman Street

Dundee

DD3 7LD

36 Mains Road

Dundee

(GJ's)

Public House *

 

The Board, having heard from an agent on behalf of the applicant agreed to grant the above application.

 

4

William McKenzie

Inglefield

68 Dalkeith Road

Dundee

2 Dalgleish Road

Dundee

(Carlton House Hotel)

Restricted Hotel

 

The Board, having heard from an agent on behalf of the applicant agreed to grant the above application.

 

5

Spirit Group Retail Limited

107 Station Street

Burton on Trent

Staffordshire

DE14 1BZ and

Martin Howley

31 Glendevon Way

Carfin

Motherwell

ML1 4EP

Camperdown Leisure Park

Drayton Drive

Dundee

(Outside Inn)

Hotel

 

The Board, having heard from an officer from Environmental Health and Consumer Protection and an agent on behalf of the applicant agreed to grant the above application.

 

6

Brian Thoresen

46 Woodlands Terrace

Dundee

DD4 9BA

134 Broughty Ferry Road

Dundee

(Off sale)

Off-Sale

 

The Board agreed not to consider the above application.

(b) APPLICATION FOR PERMANENT TRANSFER - SECTION 25(1)

 

 

Name

Address of Premises

Type of Licence

 

1

Akmal Hayat

Prioryview

Mid Road

Lunanhead

Forfar

DD8 3NX

17/18 Happyhillock Shopping Centre

Happyhillock Road

Dundee

(Hayat)

Off-Sale

 

The Board, having taken legal advice on the relevancy of an observation from the Chief Constable agreed to grant the above application.

 

2

Iqbal Hussain

140 Perth Road

Dundee

DD1 1JW

and Rahim Razak

14 Lorimer Street

Dundee

DD3 6RZ

(Ground and First Floor)

140/142 Perth Road

Dundee

(Babu G)

Restaurant

 

The Board, having heard from the Chief Constable's representative, and an agent on behalf of the applicant, agreed to grant the above application.

 

3

Karen Marr

68 Albany Road

Broughty Ferry

Dundee

40 Coupar Angus Road

Dundee

(The Park Hotel)

Hotel

 

The Board agreed to grant the above application.

 

4

Reehan Ul-Haq

58 Strachan Avenue

Broughty Ferry

Dundee

DD5 1RF

65/67 Macalpine Road

Dundee

(Off Sale)

Off-Sale

 

The Board, having taken legal advice on the relevancy of an observation from the Chief Constable, agreed to grant the above application.

 

5

Helen Meldrum

Silverknowes

Leuch Road

Auchterhouse

DD3 OQS

2 Dalgleish Road

Dundee

(Carlton House Hotel)

Restricted Hotel

 

The Board agreed to grant the above application.

 

(c) APPLICATION FOR MUSICAL ENTERTAINMENT CONSENT

 

 

Name

Address of Premises

Type of Licence

 

1

Jay Libb Inns

98 Nethergate

Dundee

DD1 4EL

and Margaret Simeon

23 Silverlink Avenue

Dundee

DD4 0SB

98 Nethergate

Dundee

DD1 4EL

(Castaways)

Public House

(New Licence including Sunday opening)

 

Music system and TV during permitted hours and karaoke Fridays and Saturdays during permitted hours and any extension thereof.

 

The Board noted that the above application had been withdrawn.

 

(d) APPLICATION FOR CHILDREN'S CERTIFICATE

 

 

Name

Address of Premises

Type of Licence

 

1

Ram Basra

95 Ancrum Road

Dundee

1/3 King Street

Dundee

(Town House)

Public House *$

 

The Board agreed to refuse the above application.

 

(e) APPLICATION FOR GRANT (INCLUDING PROVISIONAL GRANT) OF LICENCE

 

 

Name

Address of Premises

Type of Licence

 

1

Jay Libb Inns

98 Nethergate

Dundee

DD1 4EL

and Margaret Simeon

23 Silverlink Avenue

Dundee

DD4 0SB

98 Nethergate

Dundee

DD1 4EL

(Castaways)

Public House

(New Licence)

including Sunday opening

 

The Board noted that the above application had been withdrawn.

 

 

 

 

NEIL I C POWRIE, Chairman.